232) Pet Sematary (1989)

Halloween 2025’s rewind of terror ’80s horror movie thread extravaganza - the revenge! (Part ten)

"Sometimes... dead is better." 

Director
Mary Lambert

Cast
Dale Midkiff - Louis Creed 
Denise Crosby - Rachel Goldman-Creed
Blaze Berdahl - Ellie Creed
Miko Hughes - Gage Creed
Fred Gwynne - Jud Crandall
Brad Greenquist - Victor Pascow
Andrew Hubatsek - Zelda Goldman

A thread of 1980s horror movies would feel incomplete or ill considered without at least one movie based on something by horror writer Stephen King. We're talking Stephen King before "X" was a thing where King can be found tossing out all sorts of random non-sensical posts. 

Most of King's iconic movie adaptations came out in the 1980s - "The Shining" (1980), "Cujo" (1982), "Christine" (1983), "Children of the Corn" (1984), "Stand by Me" (1986), and this movie, "Pet Sematary." 

In my review of "Day of the Dead," I made some comments about how zombie movies generally speaking tend to be repetitive and as slow as the zombies they depict. 

To be fair, I including a handful of zombie movies that are actually well made and entertaining. 

The 1989 back-from-the-dead horror flick, "Pet Sematary," based on the 1983 novel by Stephen King, stands far above any zombie movie I've ever seen. 

I've seen this movie, as well as the 2019 remake, before I read King's book. I consider it to be the scariest King novel I've read, and I've read a bunch of his books.   

Like the novel, the movie "Pet Sematary" has a bleak tone, highly unsettling atmosphere, and a despairingly dark story that goes places other horror tries to reach but doesn't quite get to. 

In this movie, Dr. Louis Creed (Dale Midkiff) moves his wife, Rachel (Denise Crosby) along with their daughter, Ellie (Blaze Berdahl) and their younger son, Gage (Miko Hughes) from Chicago to the small country town of Ludlow, Maine. 

Blaze Berdahl, Dale Midkiff, and Fred Gwynne in 'Pet Sematary.'

Louis took a position as a local small-town doctor. Their gorgeous country home sits near a highway road highly used by trucks from a nearby factory down the road.  

The Creeds are welcomed by their elderly neighbor, Jud Crandall (Fred Gwynne). After getting to know Jud, they ask him about a trail nearby their house. 

He tells them it leads to a children's pet cemetery, and that he'll take them down there sometime. 

When they all finally go to check out the cemetery, the sign above the enterence spells cemetery, "sematary." As trucks whiz by down the highway, many a pet have been victims of those trucks. Hence, the burial ground for pets. 

While starting off his new job as the new local doctor, college students bring in a fellow college student named Victor Pascow who was hit by a car while on a jog and has suffered severe head trauma. 

As Louis prepares to examine his injuries, Victor suddenly awakens long enough to tell the doc not to venture past the pet cemetery as the ground is "sour." After that, Victor dies. 

His ghost visits Louis late that same night and has him follow as he leads Louis to the cemetery to warn him not to "cross the barrier." Of course, Louis doesn't know what to make of this, or what Victor means. Victor tells him he's trying to help in return for Louis trying to help him. 

While the family is away at Rachel's parent's house back in Chicago for Thanksgiving, Louis stays home. He doesn't quite get along with his father-in-law, and he has to work. 

Ellie had previously been worried that her pet cat, Church, would be another victim to the trucks that fly past on the highway and end up in the "pet sematary."  

Such is Church's fate. Jud finds the cat's remains and Louis doesn't know how he's going to break the news to his little girl when she gets back from Chicago.

But Jud has a recommendation. One he'll later deeply regret. 

He takes Louis to the ancient Miꞌkmaq burial ground past the cemetery to bury Church. Jud instructs him not to tell anyone about what they did. 

The next day, Church is back home seemingly alive. However, he's not the friendly pet cat he was before getting hit by a truck. 

Louis, of course, has tons of questions for Jud beginning with, "what did we do?". 

He tells Louis about his experiences with the burial ground back when he was a young man. And though Church has a much different personality, at least Ellie won't have to suffer the loss of her cat. 

Jud really regrets divulging this information about the burial ground to Louis after his little Gage is tragically killed by a truck. That's when the story really turns dark. 

"Pet Sematary" is uncomfortable for me to watch. 

Like the book, this movie went places other horror movies before it hadn't gone. It doesn't present the reality of death in a way that takes the edge off that inevitable part of life. 

And the movie is one of the creepiest and far-reaching flicks of the decade. It takes death as a real part of life and as a concept, and uses it to play around with the audiences' imagination to make them think "what if." King uses that question, "what if"in most, if not all, of his stories. It's what strikes a chord of trepidation and fear among his readers. 

"Pet Sematary" isn't just scary because of the monsters and creepy things in it. It's the subject matter of death and how bluntly it's depicted. That's what'll keep you up after watching. 

The movie takes its moral that death, though painful, is a necessity. To eliminate it is against nature. It's an effective method that gives this movie its staying power, for sure. 

Though it's a dead-rising-from-the-grave movie, the originality is the most effective I've seen from a film.

The story doesn't turn the return-of-the-dead premise into an emotional feast of good feelings and reunions. Nor does it turn the risen dead into brain-eating zombies. 

The story explores human grief, denial and human aversion to the fact of death. The movie doesn't tackle the what-if question in bringing the dead back to life, especially when the pain of loss stings the most sharply, into some typical zombie horror movie audiences have already seen. There's a lot of depth in the story, thanks to director Mary Lambert. 

Brad Greenquist (left) as Victor Pascow.

The story goes further into the realm of life, death, and strong human emotions that spur the main character to cross boundaries that once crossed can't really be returned from. That crossing leads to the destruction of the main character's family, emotions, and his son. "Sometimes, dead is better," Judd tells him. "Pet Sematary" is certainly the most intense "wish-gone-wrong" movie I've seen. 

It's difficult to compare "Pet Sematary" to any other movie. 

The 2001 movie "The Others" explores death and life after death as the main character is a mother protecting her children. "The Sixth Sense" from 1999 also deals with the subject of death amidst a horror movie tone in a unique way as well. 

One movie that comes close is the 1985 horror movie "Re-Animator" based on the work of H. P. Lovecraft. "Re-Animator" relies a lot on shock, grotesqueries, gore and a fair amount of comedy. 

There is a horror movie from 2011 called "Wake Wood" that has some similarities to "Pet Sematary" in that two parents participate in a ritual to resurrect their deceased daughter. When it works, their returned daughter isn't quite the same as she was before. 

"Pet Sematary" managed to spawn a sequel, "Pet Sematary II" in 1992 and a remake in 2019. There's also a prequel to the remake called "Pet Sematary: Bloodlines" from 2023. I saw the remake and had mixed feelings about it. I found it inferior to this movie. But that's another commentary for another time. 

Anyways, hands down, this movie is one of the most uncomfortable movies I've sat through. Not because it's a terrible movie, but because the film takes the reality of death, its role in human existance, and really hammers in the reality of it. It does that more effectively than any other movie, horror or otherwise, that I've seen. It captures that very element from King's novel spot-on.